Sugar Hill Creamery: Harlem’s Best Ice Cream & Menu
Sugar Hill Creamery New York
A Sweet Slice of Harlem Heaven
Nestled in the historic Harlem neighborhood of New York City, Sugar Hill Creamery is more than just an ice cream parlor – it’s a community hub where creamy dreams come true. The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by the nostalgic aroma of waffle cones and the cheerful chatter of happy customers. With its retro-modern decor featuring pops of pastel colors and vintage ice cream memorabilia, this charming spot perfectly blends old-school charm with contemporary cool.
Location: 184 Lenox Ave, New York, NY 10027
Opening Hours: Monday-Thursday 12pm-10pm, Friday-Saturday 12pm-11pm, Sunday 12pm-9pm
Contact: (212) 234-1111 | info@sugarhillcreamery.com
Menu Highlights
Sugar Hill Creamery’s menu is a love letter to classic flavors with innovative twists that celebrate Harlem’s rich cultural heritage. Here are some must-try selections:
- Harlem Honeycomb: Velvety vanilla ice cream swirled with golden honeycomb candy.
- Ube Purple Yam: Vibrant Filipino-inspired purple yam with coconut undertones.
- Brown Butter Bourbon: Sophisticated adult treat with smooth bourbon infusion.
- Sweet Potato Pie: Creamy homage to Southern tradition with cinnamon spice.
- Mango Chile Lime: Tropical mango meets zesty lime and subtle heat.
- Black Sesame: Nutty, toasty Japanese-inspired flavor with elegant sophistication.
- Strawberry Basil: Fresh berry sweetness balanced with herbal basil notes.
- Vegan Chocolate Fudge: Rich dairy-free chocolate that satisfies any craving.
- Lavender Shortbread: Floral lavender paired with buttery cookie crumbles.
- Coffee Toffee: Bold coffee ice cream with crunchy toffee bits.
The Sugar Hill Experience
Walking into Sugar Hill Creamery feels like stepping into a Wes Anderson film – every detail is thoughtfully curated. The pastel pink and mint green walls adorned with local art create an Instagram-worthy backdrop, while the vintage ice cream counter adds nostalgic charm. Seating options range from cozy two-tops to a communal table where strangers often become friends over shared sundae experiences.
The staff radiates genuine warmth, remembering regulars by name and patiently guiding new visitors through flavor selections. They’ll gladly offer samples (try before you commit!) and share the stories behind their small-batch creations. Pricing is reasonable for artisanal quality, with single scoops around $5 and creative sundaes topping out at $12.
Weekends buzz with energy as families, date-night couples, and friend groups create sweet memories. Midweek afternoons offer a more relaxed vibe, perfect for enjoying a cone while people-watching through the large picture windows. Seasonal decorations and rotating flavors keep the experience fresh no matter when you visit.
Final Scoop
While every flavor at Sugar Hill Creamery deserves applause, the Harlem Honeycomb and Ube Purple Yam have achieved legendary status among regulars. The former perfectly balances sweet and crunchy, while the latter’s striking color and unique taste make it a conversation starter.
This parlor particularly appeals to:
- Foodies seeking innovative flavor combinations
- Families wanting quality treats in a welcoming space
- Instagrammers hunting for photogenic desserts
- Locals supporting Black-owned businesses
- Tourists craving authentic Harlem experiences
In my last visit, I lingered over a Brown Butter Bourbon scoop while chatting with the owner about her inspiration. The care poured into every aspect – from sourcing local ingredients to training staff – explains why this spot consistently draws lines out the door. It’s not just ice cream; it’s edible happiness served with Harlem pride.
Some of the images and information is taken from other sources.
Sugar Hill Creamery New York, Sugar Hill Creamery Harlem ice cream, Sugar Hill Creamery menu prices, Sugar Hill Creamery best flavors, Sugar Hill Creamery vegan options, Sugar Hill Creamery opening hours, Sugar Hill Creamery contact number, Sugar Hill Creamery location map, Sugar Hill Creamery black-owned business, Sugar Hill Creamery artisanal ice cream, Sugar Hill Creamery Ube Purple Yam, Sugar Hill Creamery Harlem Honeycomb, Sugar Hill Creamery seasonal flavors, Sugar Hill Creamery dessert parlor, Sugar Hill Creamery New York reviews, Sugar Hill Creamery Instagram-worthy desserts, Sugar Hill Creamery family-friendly spot, Sugar Hill Creamery date night ideas, Sugar Hill Creamery takeout options, Sugar Hill Creamery local ingredients.
“`
