OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

Calculate Protein and Calories

Nestled in the heart of New York’s vibrant food scene, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is a whimsical paradise for dessert lovers. Located at 75 East 4th Street in Manhattan’s East Village, this quirky ice cream parlor has been delighting locals and tourists alike with its innovative flavors and playful atmosphere since its opening. The shop’s retro-modern decor, featuring pastel colors and quirky artwork, creates a fun, Instagram-worthy setting that perfectly complements its creative menu.

Open from 12 PM to 11 PM daily (with extended hours until midnight on weekends), OddFellows is the perfect spot for an afternoon treat or a late-night dessert run. You can reach them at (212) 477-7151 for any inquiries or to check on their ever-changing seasonal offerings.

Menu Highlights

OddFellows’ menu is a delightful mix of classic favorites and boundary-pushing creations that will make your taste buds dance. Here are some of their most popular offerings:

• Miso Cherry: Sweet cherries meet umami miso in this unexpected delight.
• Burnt Marshmallow: Toasty, creamy perfection that tastes like campfire memories.
• Cornbread: Buttery, crumbly goodness that’s surprisingly addictive.
• Everything Bagel: Cream cheese ice cream with bagel bits – NYC in a scoop.
• Strawberry Pink Peppercorn: Sweet berries with a spicy, floral kick.
• Chocolate Olive Oil: Rich cocoa balanced with fruity olive oil notes.
• Honey Lavender: Floral, soothing, and just the right amount sweet.
• Maple Bacon: Breakfast-inspired goodness with crispy bacon pieces.
• Black Licorice: For anise lovers – bold, herbal, and creamy.
• Vietnamese Coffee: Strong, aromatic coffee flavor with sweetened condensed milk.
• Salted Caramel: Classic done right – buttery, salty, and sweet.
• Peanut Butter Curry: Unexpected spice meets nutty creaminess.
• Lemon Poppyseed: Bright citrus with crunchy poppyseed texture.
• Matcha White Chocolate: Earthy green tea meets creamy sweetness.
• Birthday Cake: Funfetti-filled nostalgia in every bite.

The OddFellows Experience

Interior & Atmosphere

Walking into OddFellows feels like stepping into a Wes Anderson film – in the best possible way. The space is small but thoughtfully designed, with pastel pink walls, mint green accents, and playful neon signs. Quirky art pieces and vintage ice cream memorabilia add to the charm, while the open kitchen lets you watch the magic happen. Seating is limited to a few stools along the window counter, encouraging a lively, communal vibe where strangers often bond over their flavor choices.

Service & Staff

The staff at OddFellows are as delightful as the ice cream they serve. Knowledgeable without being pretentious, they’re happy to let you sample multiple flavors before committing. Their genuine enthusiasm for the product is infectious – ask about any flavor, and you’ll get a passionate explanation of its inspiration and ingredients. During peak hours, lines can get long (a testament to their popularity), but the staff keeps things moving efficiently.

Pricing & Value

With single scoops starting at $5 and sundaes around $10, OddFellows sits at the premium end of the ice cream spectrum – but the quality justifies the price. Portions are generous, flavors are complex, and ingredients are top-notch. Their rotating seasonal offerings mean there’s always something new to try, encouraging repeat visits. For those wanting to take the experience home, pints are available for $12-$15 depending on the flavor.

Vibe & Clientele

OddFellows attracts a diverse crowd – from hipster foodies seeking the next Instagrammable dessert to families with wide-eyed kids marveling at the colorful displays. The vibe is consistently upbeat and inclusive, with the hum of excited conversations about flavor discoveries filling the air. It’s the kind of place where you might strike up a conversation with your neighbor about their ice cream choice, sharing recommendations and reactions.

Conclusion

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. isn’t just an ice cream shop – it’s a culinary adventure that challenges and delights in equal measure. While their “Everything Bagel” and “Burnt Marshmallow” flavors have achieved cult status, the real magic lies in their ever-changing roster of innovative creations. This is the perfect spot for adventurous eaters, dessert enthusiasts, or anyone looking to break free from vanilla (though their vanilla is excellent too).

In my visits, I’ve been consistently impressed by how OddFellows balances creativity with quality. Even their most unusual flavors never feel like gimmicks – each is carefully crafted to deliver a harmonious taste experience. Whether you’re a New York local or just visiting, OddFellows deserves a spot on your must-try list. Just be warned: after one visit, you might find yourself dreaming about their unique flavor combinations until your next scoop.

Some of the images and information are taken from other sources.