OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

Welcome to OddFellows – New York’s Most Creative Ice Cream Experience

Nestled in the heart of New York City, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is more than just an ice cream parlor – it’s a whimsical culinary adventure that delights locals and tourists alike. Located at 75 East 4th Street in the vibrant East Village, this quirky spot has become a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth and a sense of adventure.

The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a playful, retro-inspired interior with pastel colors, quirky artwork, and an infectious energy that makes you feel like a kid again. Open from 12 PM to 11 PM daily (with slightly shorter hours on Sundays), it’s the perfect place for an afternoon treat or a post-dinner indulgence. Need to check something before visiting? Give them a call at (347) 599-0556 – their friendly staff is always happy to help.

Menu Highlights: Where Creativity Meets Deliciousness

OddFellows is famous for pushing the boundaries of traditional ice cream flavors while maintaining incredible taste. Here are some of their most popular creations:

• Miso Cherry: Sweet cherries meet umami miso in this unexpectedly perfect pairing.
• Everything Bagel: Cream cheese ice cream with actual bagel pieces – yes, really!
• Cornbread: Buttery, slightly sweet, and utterly addictive cornbread-flavored delight.
• Chocolate Hazelnut: A rich, nutty twist on classic chocolate that’s impossible to resist.
• Strawberry Pink Peppercorn: Sweet berries with a surprising spicy kick that lingers.
• Blackberry Mojito: Refreshing mint-lime sorbet with juicy blackberry swirls.
• Maple Bacon: Sweet maple ice cream with crispy, salty bacon bits throughout.
• Vietnamese Coffee: Strong, aromatic coffee flavor with sweet condensed milk notes.
• Olive Oil: Surprisingly sophisticated, with a smooth, luxurious texture.
• Birthday Cake: Funfetti-studded vanilla with frosting swirls – pure nostalgia.

Their menu changes frequently with seasonal specials, so there’s always something new to try. Vegans rejoice – they always have excellent dairy-free options too!

The Complete OddFellows Experience

Beyond the incredible ice cream, what makes OddFellows special is the complete experience. The space is small but bursting with personality – think pink walls, neon signs, and a cheerful, slightly chaotic energy that feels authentically New York. Seating is limited (just a few stools along the window), but most people don’t mind eating their cones while strolling through the neighborhood.

Service is fast and friendly, with staff who genuinely seem to love what they do. They’ll happily let you sample multiple flavors before deciding – a blessing when everything sounds so good! Pricing is reasonable for NYC, with single scoops around $5 and sundaes or special creations going up to $10-12.

The vibe is unpretentious but cool – you’ll see everyone from families with excited kids to hipster couples on dates to tourists who’ve heard the buzz. The constant line out the door (which moves surprisingly fast) is testament to how beloved this place is.

Final Scoop: Is OddFellows Worth the Hype?

Absolutely. While everything at OddFellows is delicious, you can’t leave without trying their signature Miso Cherry or the mind-bending Everything Bagel flavor – they perfectly represent the shop’s playful, boundary-pushing approach. The Cornbread and Vietnamese Coffee are close runners-up for most addictive flavors.

This is the perfect spot for adventurous eaters, Instagrammers looking for colorful treats, or anyone who thinks ice cream should be more than just vanilla and chocolate (though they do those classics exceptionally well too). Even if you’re skeptical about flavors like olive oil or everything bagel, trust the process – OddFellows has a magical way of making unusual combinations work.

In my many visits, I’ve never been disappointed. The quality is consistently excellent, the flavors are genuinely creative (not just weird for weirdness’ sake), and there’s an undeniable joy to the whole experience. Whether you’re a New Yorker or just visiting, OddFellows is one of those special places that makes the city sweeter – literally and figuratively.

Some of the images and information is taken from other sources.

“`