🏪 Gage & Tollner – A Timeless New York Dining Experience

Step into Gage & Tollner, a legendary New York restaurant where history meets modern culinary excellence. Known for its revival of classic dishes and stunning Victorian-era decor, this Brooklyn gem offers a dining experience that’s both nostalgic and fresh. Whether you’re craving seafood, steak, or craft cocktails, Gage & Tollner delivers unforgettable flavors in an elegant setting.

📍 Restaurant Details

Location: 372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Ambience: Elegant, vintage-inspired with warm lighting, mahogany woodwork, and a touch of old-world charm.

Opening Hours:
Monday – Thursday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Friday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 5:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Contact: (718) 875-5181 | Website | Instagram

🍽️ Menu Highlights

Gage & Tollner’s menu blends classic American fare with inventive twists. Here are the must-try dishes:

• Dry-Aged Ribeye Steak – Perfectly marbled, smoky, and served with herb butter.
• Lobster Thermidor – Rich, creamy lobster baked with gruyère and brandy.
• Clams Casino – Buttery clams topped with crispy bacon and peppers.
• Oysters Rockefeller – Fresh oysters baked with spinach, Pernod, and breadcrumbs.
• Martini – A timeless gin or vodka martini, stirred to perfection.
• Baked Alaska – Flaming meringue dessert with ice cream and cake.

📝 More About the Restaurant

Interior & Decor

Gage & Tollner’s interior is a love letter to the Gilded Age, with restored gaslight chandeliers, velvet banquettes, and gilded mirrors. The space feels grand yet intimate, making it ideal for both romantic dinners and celebratory gatherings.

Service

The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, offering recommendations with genuine warmth. Service strikes a balance between polished and unpretentious—expect prompt refills and thoughtful pacing.

Pricing

Prices reflect the upscale experience (entrées range from $30–$60), but the quality justifies the cost. Happy hour and bar snacks provide more affordable options.

Unique Features

The restaurant houses a hidden basement bar, The Sunken Harbor Club, serving tropical cocktails in a moody, nautical-themed space. Live piano music on weekends adds to the ambiance.

🌟 Conclusion & Review

Gage & Tollner is a triumph of historic preservation and culinary innovation. Standouts like the Dry-Aged Ribeye and Lobster Thermidor are absolute must-orders. Ideal for foodies, couples, or anyone seeking a taste of New York’s golden age, this restaurant offers a rare blend of nostalgia and excellence. Whether you’re toasting with a martini or savoring dessert, every moment here feels special.

Note: Some of the images and information are taken from other sources.

 

Gage & Tollner New York, Gage & Tollner Brooklyn, Gage & Tollner menu, Gage & Tollner reservations, Gage & Tollner steakhouse, Gage & Tollner lobster thermidor, Gage & Tollner dry-aged ribeye, Gage & Tollner oysters Rockefeller, Gage & Tollner cocktails, Gage & Tollner Sunken Harbor Club, Gage & Tollner historic restaurant, Gage & Tollner dress code, Gage & Tollner happy hour, Gage & Tollner reviews, Gage & Tollner best dishes, Gage & Tollner Brooklyn dining, Gage & Tollner elegant ambience, Gage & Tollner Victorian decor, Gage & Tollner romantic dinner, Gage & Tollner group dining.

“`