Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago: Your Ultimate Menu & Shop Guide

Welcome, fellow sweet tooths, to a deep dive into one of Chicago’s most beloved dessert destinations: Andy’s Frozen Custard! Nestled in the vibrant Lincoln Park neighborhood at 260 W. Fullerton Ave, Chicago, IL 60614, Andy’s offers a nostalgic, heartwarming experience with every creamy, dreamy scoop. From the moment you approach, the bright, inviting exterior promises a delightful escape, perfect for families, couples on a sweet date, or anyone craving a moment of pure bliss. The air is often filled with the excited chatter of happy customers and the sweet scent of freshly made custard.

Conveniently located in a bustling part of the city, Andy’s Frozen Custard in Lincoln Park is easily accessible and a perfect stop after exploring nearby attractions or enjoying a meal. They understand that a craving for frozen custard can strike at any time, which is why their generous opening hours cater to early afternoon treats and late-night indulgences. You can satisfy your sweet tooth Sunday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and extend your enjoyment on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 12:00 AM. Should you have any questions or wish to inquire about their daily special, don’t hesitate to reach out to their friendly team at (773) 857-4100. Prepare to be whisked away to a world of creamy delight where every visit feels like a celebration.

Calculate Your Calories & Protein Here!

Menu Highlights: Dive into Andy’s Frozen Delights!

Andy’s Frozen Custard isn’t just about dessert; it’s about an experience built on the foundation of freshly made, rich, and creamy frozen custard. Their menu is a vibrant tapestry of classic treats and innovative concoctions, designed to tantalize every palate. Made hourly with only the finest ingredients, Andy’s custard boasts a smooth texture and unparalleled flavor that sets it apart. Whether you’re a fan of loaded concretes, classic sundaes, or a simple, perfect cone, there’s something extraordinary waiting for you.

Here’s a detailed look at the scrumptious offerings you can find at Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago:

Signature Concretes – Blended Perfection

Andy’s concretes are legendary – thick, creamy frozen custard blended with your favorite toppings to create a treat that’s spoon-standingly good.

James Brown Funky Jackhammer: Peanut butter, banana, and hot fudge blended into creamy vanilla custard, with a fudge core.
Andy’s Combo: Vanilla custard, juicy strawberries, sweet blueberries, and delicious cheesecake pieces mixed throughout.
Triple Chocolate Concrete: A rich chocolate custard base, loaded with chocolate chips, gooey hot fudge, and soft brownie bits.
BootDaddy Concrete: Vanilla custard swirled with hot fudge, rich caramel, crunchy pecans, and decadent brownie pieces.
Rico Suave: Vanilla custard infused with fresh bananas, creamy peanut butter, and a generous drizzle of melted chocolate.
Ozark Turtle: Vanilla custard featuring a classic combination of hot fudge, smooth caramel, and crunchy toasted pecans.
Strawberry Shortcake Concrete: Creamy vanilla custard blended with fresh, sweet strawberries and fluffy, tender shortcake pieces.
Mint Oreo Concrete: Refreshing mint syrup and classic crushed Oreo cookies perfectly blended into velvety vanilla custard.
Butter Pecan Concrete: Rich vanilla custard generously mixed with crunchy butter pecan pieces and a luscious caramel drizzle.
Cherry Chocolate Chip Concrete: Vanilla custard combined with sweet cherry topping and an abundance of mini chocolate chips.
S’mores Jackhammer: Vanilla custard, graham crackers, marshmallow crème, and a gooey hot fudge center.
Cookie Dough Concrete: Smooth vanilla custard embracing generous chunks of irresistible, edible chocolate chip cookie dough.
Pecan Delight Concrete: Vanilla custard blended with roasted pecans and rich, buttery caramel sauce. A nutty dream.
Banana Fudge Concrete: Fresh ripe bananas and decadent hot fudge swirled into smooth vanilla custard.

Irresistible Sundaes – Classic & Creative

For those who prefer their toppings artfully arranged, Andy’s sundaes are picture-perfect masterpieces, piled high with deliciousness.

Banana Split: Three scoops of custard, split banana, three toppings, nuts, whipped cream, and a cherry.
Fudge Brownie Sundae: A warm, gooey brownie crowned with vanilla custard, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry.
Caramel Cashew Sundae: Creamy vanilla custard blanketed in rich caramel sauce and crunchy roasted cashews.
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae: Fluffy shortcake, vanilla custard, fresh strawberries, and generous dollops of whipped cream.
Chocolate Lovers Sundae: Decadent chocolate custard, hot fudge, chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and sprinkles.
Pecan Pie Sundae: Vanilla custard topped with warm, sweet pecan pie filling, a caramel drizzle, and whipped topping.
Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae: Vanilla custard, creamy peanut butter topping, and warm, rich hot fudge.

Shakes, Malts & Floats – Sip on Sweetness

Thirsty for a treat? Andy’s offers thick, creamy shakes and malts, plus fizzy floats that are perfect for a refreshing pick-me-up.

Vanilla Shake: Classic smooth, creamy vanilla custard blended perfectly into a refreshing, slurpable shake.
Chocolate Malt: Rich chocolate custard and classic malt powder blended for a nostalgic, frothy treat.
Strawberry Shake: Bursting with fresh strawberry flavor, mixed with smooth vanilla custard. Pure fruity delight.
Peanut Butter Shake: Creamy, nutty peanut butter blended with sweet vanilla custard for an indulgent sip.
Root Beer Float: Classic frothy root beer poured over a generous scoop of creamy vanilla custard.
Coke Float: Refreshing Coca-Cola combined with smooth, sweet vanilla custard for a bubbly treat.

Cones & Dishes – Simple Perfection

Sometimes, all you need is the pure, unadulterated joy of Andy’s freshly made frozen custard.

Vanilla Custard Cone: The classic smooth, creamy vanilla frozen custard in a crispy, satisfying cone.
Chocolate Custard Cone: Rich, decadent chocolate frozen custard swirled high in a classic crispy cone.
Twist Cone: A perfect swirl of vanilla and chocolate frozen custard, offering the best of both worlds.
Plain Custard Dish: Simple, pure, delicious vanilla or chocolate frozen custard served in a convenient cup.

Seasonal & Specialty Treats – Limited Time Delights

Andy’s keeps things exciting with a rotating menu of seasonal favorites and special concoctions that are worth looking out for!

Pumpkin Pie Concrete (Fall): Real pumpkin, crumbled pie crust, and vanilla custard create a perfect autumnal delight.
Key Lime Pie Concrete (Summer): Tart key lime, crunchy graham cracker, and creamy vanilla custard for a summer escape.
Hot Fudge Cake: Warm, rich chocolate cake, topped with vanilla custard, copious hot fudge, and whipped cream.
Andygator: Vanilla custard, strawberries, and a chocolate crunch cone piece mixed into pure bliss.

More Than Just Custard: The Andy’s Experience

Stepping into Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago is an immediate mood booster. The interior radiates a clean, cheerful, and family-friendly atmosphere, often featuring a bright, retro-inspired aesthetic with vibrant colors and comfortable seating. Service is consistently speedy and remarkably friendly, reflecting a staff genuinely happy to serve up smiles alongside their delicious treats. Pricing is very reasonable for the quality and generous portion sizes, offering excellent value. The vibe is always upbeat and bustling, making it a lively spot for an afternoon pick-me-up or a late-night dessert run with friends and family.

Your Sweet Escape Awaits at Andy’s Chicago

Andy’s Frozen Custard in Chicago is truly a jewel in the city’s dessert scene. While every item on their menu is crafted with care, the Ozark Turtle Concrete, with its perfect blend of hot fudge, caramel, and pecans, remains an all-time crowd-pleaser. The James Brown Funky Jackhammer is another legendary creation, delivering a unique and memorable flavor experience. This is the perfect spot for anyone who appreciates high-quality, freshly made frozen custard – from families looking for a fun outing to individuals craving a nostalgic treat, or even dessert connoisseurs seeking their next sweet obsession. My mini-review? Simply outstanding! Andy’s delivers on its promise of rich, creamy indulgence every single time, making it a must-visit for any dessert lover in Chicago.

some of the images and information is taken from other sources

Discover Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s famous concretes, explore Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s full menu, find Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s opening hours, locate Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s address, enjoy Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s sundaes, taste Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s shakes, experience Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s quality, plan your visit to Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago, read Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago reviews, check Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago seasonal items, order Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago online, find Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago contact, learn about Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago specials, get directions to Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago, try Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s Jackhammers, indulge in Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s desserts, savor Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s flavors, browse Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago’s offerings, enjoy a treat at Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago, explore the Andy’s Frozen Custard Chicago experience.